Click here to receive your FREE subscription to Campus Technology
Cover Story
Data Mining & Business Intelligence >> Open for Business
2/1/2007
How to Pick an Open Source App
Experts say that selecting good open source software isn’t easier than choosing the right conventional software package, it’s just different. Beyond the usual tests that a CIO would run on any kind of software, smart open source shoppers perform some additional due diligence as well. Unlike conventional software, with open source, safety lies not in the company, but with the users: A large user base is insurance that if something goes wrong with your program, other people are likely to be having the same problem—and someone out there may decide to solve it. The first step in the kind of detective work that will help you determine solidity of product, comes down to asking five questions:
- Have there been a large number of downloads of the program? The more downloads, the more likely that the user base is large.
- Are there a lot of comments about the software in forums? A quick read of the commentary by users and developers will give you a sense of whether the software has a strong user base, consultants say. In addition, “We used the newsgroup quite heavily to find out things that we didn’t know,” reports Rebecca Gribble, manager of decision support services at Indiana University.
- In examining the postings, are issues raised and then resolved? If they’re not, it can be an indication that the open source project is not all that solid. “You want to see that there’s definitely project activity,” says Mark Madsen, an IT consultant based in Rogue River, OR.
- Does there seem to be an active group of developers? If an open source project is still under way, skimming a selection of posts is a good way to get a sense of whether there is a good team behind the program.
- Are there staff members available to answer questions? Amy Stephen, a data and internet specialist for the University of Nebraska, says she passed on one open source BI provider because she couldn’t get anyone to return her calls, and she figured that the behavior was unlikely to get better after the university adopted the application.
Higher and Lower Risks
Still, if open source BI is so great, why haven’t more campus CIOs heard more about it? One reason, says di Paolantonio, is that open source software isn’t “out there,” being hawked by high-priced salespeople. Since the software can be downloaded for free or for a minimal fee, the marketing budget is much lower, he says. As a result, he adds, “it’s not real likely that you’re going to find some Armani-suited field service guy who pulls down a million dollar commission check, trying to convince you to opt for open source BI.”
Another reason: the perception by some CIOs that a commercial company is somehow more accountable, even through legal recourse (a commercial vendor, after all, can be vulnerable to litigation if its product doesn’t work). Yet, many open source proponents feel the option of legal recourse is more or less a false sense of security that doesn’t pan out in the real world anyway. (How many technology vendors has your institution sued recently?)
Open source BI is also a newcomer to the technology scene, and new software is often not quite housebroken. Consultants and vendors caution that very small IT departments may have difficulty installing the programs. “If your IT department consists of close to zero technical staff, you might have some challenges,” says Lance Walter, VP of marketing for Pentaho.
Recommended Reading
- Sun, Stanford Working To Archive History
In May in San Francisco, experts from leading universities, libraries, and research institutions around the world met as part of an ongoing effort to address a pressing issue: archiving the world's history, right up to today.
- The Quilt Coalition Rolls Out XO Communications for High-Capacity Network Services
The Quilt, a coalition of 28 regional network organizations, has added XO Communications Services to its authorized vendor list. The Quilt represents 200 universities and thousands of other educational institutions across the United States. With this new relationship, Quilt members can purchase XO's high-speed IP transit and network transport services at competitive rates.
- Wimba Classroom 5.2 Expands Classroom Capture Support, Adds MP3 Downloads
At the NECC 2008 conference in Texas this week, Wimba launched a new version of Wimba Classroom, the virtual classroom component of the company's Collaboration Suite. The new 5.2 release expands options for classroom capture and adds a variety of other functional and ease of use features.
- Automation Chimera: Education Is Not Management
The lure of automating workflow online so human intervention is minimized is continually reinforced in the minds of higher education administrators by examples of automated campus systems such as financials, student information systems, and other enterprise systems. But what's good for management is not always good for learning.
- Cognos Releases BI Software for Linux-based IBM System z Mainframe
Cognos, which IBM acquired in January, has released an update to its business intelligence software that will run on the Linux operating system on IBM System z mainframes. IBM Cognos 8 BI was being developed by the two companies prior to the acquisition, but assimilation of Cognos into IBM accelerated development.
- Facebook and Collegiality: A Serendipitous Social Niche
Facebook is a way to greet a colleague as if she or he is on your own campus: a wave at a distance, a hello at the corner burrito place, a honk as you both leave the campus parking lot. Informal collegiality has been extended over the miles.
