Click here to receive your FREE subscription to Campus Technology
Current News
Why You Should Care Very Much About a 26-Page Legal Filing: And Thank a Bunch of Associations
4/21/2004
On April 13, a coalition of higher education associations filed a 26-page legal brief known as a "comment" with the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) opposing a Justice Department petition which asks the FCC to allow it to apply the same rules regarding wiretapping that it currently enjoys with traditional telephony to all types of broadband Internet access. Hooray for the coalition! And, thanks.
If the Justice Department loses within the FCC, as I hope it d'es, the same issues will show up on the legislative calendars in the Congress and the Senate. If you feel strongly about these issues, please use the link provided at the end of this article to express your concerns to your elected officials. (The link will tell you who they are and provide contact information instantly, based on your zip code.)
I am personally grateful for the coalition's filing (PDF) and hope its work to oppose this end run around the legislative process is successful. I also hope that it keeps its eyes on future legislation, in 2005 or 2006, which the Bush administration is likely to bring before Congress to achieve the same goals. At least that would be the appropriate route, but I hope it fails there, too.
The basic argument is that the Justice Department is attempting in its petition to bring all broadband access within the scope of previous legislation that was intended to apply only to traditional telephony would inhibit innovation, compromise privacy, and impose needless costs at a time when higher education budgets, especially, are already strained.
The FBI perspective on this is that "The bottom line is that law enforcement must not lose its ability to do lawfully authorized electronic surveillance merely because of changing telecommunications technology." Law enforcement officials are convinced they can do a better job with these new powers.
Well, it's hard to argue with that. But it's a little disingenuous to argue that widening the scope of federal wiretapping laws developed with traditional telephony in mind to include all broadband Internet access is something that should be done simply in an administrative branch procedure without congressional oversight. The argument here is over whether or not these are new powers or simply clarified powers, and few outside the Justice Department believe this is a clarification. Some believe that this FCC petition is merely the first wave of a series of efforts to reduce privacy expectations among the American public so as to soften up the opposition for future legislative actions - and that the motivation is not national security but pressure from the burgeoning surveillance tool industry that would love to see the $3-5B it has earned since CALEA was passed balloon into some much larger figure if the entire Internet industry has to comply.
This patriotic Vietnam veteran agrees with the higher education coalition that it "understands law enforcement's dilemma.
Recommended Reading
- Campus Security :: November 14, 2008
:::::: SECURITY SPOTLIGHT
: Smart Phone Security: New Challenges for Road Warriors
:::::: CAMPUS SECURITY NEWS
: SMobile Releases Antivirus To Protect Google Android Phones
: Blue Coat Integrates Network Appliances
: e2Campus Provides Twitter Integration in Emergency Notification System
: Moodle Gets Student Verification Capabilities
: Rave Wireless Adding BlackBerry Devices to Notification Service
: U Miami Trades IPS for Top Layer Security System
: Cornell Hardens Campus Network with Gigabit Wireless Radio Links
: U Pittsburgh Turns to Verizon Business for Automated Notification Services - IT Trends :: Thursday, November 13, 2008
:::::: CASE STUDY
:: Cornell Takes Visual Approach to Data Analysis
:::::: IT NEWS
:: Panopto Launches Hosted Lecture Capture System
:: Microsoft To Add Smooth Streaming in IIS7
:: Agile Solution Provider Rolls Out Java SDK
:: Salem CC To Enhance Self Service with Unified Digital Campus
:: Parallels Desktop 4.0 Get Performance Boost, DirectX 9.0 Support
:: Brandon U To Automate Employment Processes with EmpCenter
:: SMobile Releases Antivirus To Protect Google Android Phones - C-Level View :: November 12, 2008
:::::: EXECUTIVE VIEW
: Delta iTunes U Enhances Learning in a Familiar Web 2.0 Environment
:::::: WORTH NOTING
: Caltech Completes Parking Structure Solar Array
: Schools Take Recruitment Virtual with Online Education Expo
: Blackboard Managed Hosting Rolls Out Virtual Operating Environment
: Higher Ed Help Desk Platform Adds Web 2.0 Tools
: Moodle Gets Student Verification Capabilities - SmartClassroom :: Wednesday, November 12, 2008
:::::: TECHNOLOGY TRENDS
: Microblogging and Relevancy
:::::: NEWS and PRODUCT UPDATES
: Open Source Java Libraries Debut for uPortal
: Dimdim Launches Hosted Virtual Classroom
: ASU School of Engineering Posts 10,000th Lecture with Mediasite
: Lyon College Plans Student Laptop Rollout
: Moodle Gets Student Verification Capabilities - News Update :: Tuesday, November 11, 2008
:::::: NEWS
: Caltech Completes Parking Structure Solar Array
: Schools Take Recruitment Virtual with Online Education Expo
: Salem CC To Enhance Self Service with Unified Digital Campus
: Brandon U To Automate Employment Processes with EmpCenter
: Open Source Java Libraries Debut for uPortal
: ASU and Obsidian Collaboration Seeks to Boost Long-distance Bandwidth
: Blue Coat Integrates Network Appliances
: e2Campus Provides Twitter Integration in Emergency Notification System
: Plagiarism Detection System Adds URL Filtering, Reporting Groups - IT Trends :: Thursday, November 6, 2008
:::::: CASE STUDY
:: Small College Makes Big Leap in Wireless
:::::: IT NEWS
:: Washington U Healthcare Researchers Turn to Virtual Storage
:: Cornell Hardens Campus Network with Gigabit Wireless Radio Links
:: BYU-Idaho Turns to Web-based Facilities Management System
:: U Pittsburgh Turns to Verizon Business for Automated Notification Services
:: Universities Turn to Oracle for Web-based Services
:: Delgado CC Expands Outsourced Support Agreement with Presidium Learning
:: Security Concerns May Slow Cloud Computing Adoption
